Showing posts with label Nativity. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Nativity. Show all posts

Thursday, 2 April 2020

Problems with St Luke's Nativity Census




St Luke’s account of the birth of Jesus centres round a census that apparently took place “when Cyrenius was governor of Syria”. This required Joseph and his heavily pregnant wife to journey from Nazareth to Bethlehem because Joseph “was of the house and lineage of David” and Bethlehem was “the city of David”.

This story has always struck me as being wildly improbable. For a start, the implication of it is that everyone in Palestine at that time knew who they were descended from, going back hundreds of years, and that they also knew where their distant ancestors came from.

All sorts of questions are begged here. How far back were you supposed to go before you hit on the ancestor in question? Above all, what was the point of having to travel to your “ancestral city” – always assuming that it still existed?

There is evidence that censuses were held in various parts of the Roman Empire, but their purpose was, as Luke implies, to enable taxes to be levied. This would be done by officials travelling from place to place to see what people owned, in terms of land, animals, etc, and making their levies appropriately. This sort of census would therefore be very much like the Domesday Book survey made by King William I in England in the 11th century. There would therefore be absolutely no point in requiring people to move away from the property on which the tax would be due – they needed to be at home when the officials arrived so that all the property could be shown to them and the tax paid in person.

Another huge problem with Luke’s account is that taxation would be levied on heads of households and not their wives. Even if Joseph had to travel to Bethlehem, why on earth would he have had to take Mary with him? Surely she could have been looked after by neighbours while her husband was away? In her condition she could have gone into labour at any time on the journey, and surely Joseph would not have taken that risk.

Another difficulty with Luke’s account is that the dates do not make sense. Luke is clear that the events of the Nativity took place “in the days of Herod, the king of Judea”, and that the census was held “when Cyrenius was governor of Syria”. There is historical evidence that Cyrenius did hold a census in the newly established province of Judea, but this cannot have happened before 6 AD. However, Herod died in 4 BC!

The conclusion has to be that Luke twisted the facts to fit the story that he wanted to tell. That story involved the need to place the birth in Bethlehem but the home of Jesus in Nazareth, for reasons of fulfilling Old Testament prophesies. He may not have known about the historical impossibility of what he was saying, or he may have been relying on his readers not being interested in checking the facts for themselves, even if they had the ability to do so.

The difficulty for modern readers is that we tend to look for historical accuracy whereas that was not always the purpose of ancient writers. Luke may not have intended to deceive, and he probably saw nothing untoward in telling the story in the way that he did. From his point of view he was writing not so much a history as a historical novel, and the inaccuracies that it contained did absolutely nothing to invalidate the message that it contained. After all, if the story could include messenger angels and the “heavenly host” singing to startled shepherds, what did a few historical inventions matter?

© John Welford

Wednesday, 1 April 2020

The legend of the Three Wise Men




6th January is the Feast of the Epiphany and is traditionally the date on which the “wise men from the East” in St Matthew’s Gospel reached Bethlehem and offered their gifts of “gold, frankincense and myrrh” to the infant Jesus. It is also the date on which all Christmas decorations must be taken down if you haven’t done so already!

Did the Three Wise Men ever exist?

This is a story that has grown in the telling over the centuries. For one thing, it is only because there were three gifts that there has always been reference to three givers – Matthew says nothing about this. The wise men have also been promoted to kings in many versions of the story, although the justification for this seems to come from references in the Book of Psalms to kings bearing gifts.

It is easy to imagine how the sketchy mentions by Matthew (and no-one else) might have been given more substantial form in later years. When the story was read in a 2nd-century Christian gathering, as everyone hid in the catacombs for fear of being discovered by the Romans, a child might have asked “What were their names?” and so names were suggested . Another might have asked “What did they look like?” and an artist among the adults would have been inspired to paint them on the walls, using a measure of artistic licence.

As a result, the Christian tradition was that the three wise men were named Balthasar, Caspar and Melchior, and they were of different ages - young, middle-aged and elderly. One of them (Balthasar) was drawn as a black man. Traditions, once established, are hard to break, and so artists all down the centuries have followed the same conventions.

Cologne Cathedral and the Three Wise Men

According to tradition, the bones of the three wise men were preserved and eventually found their way to Germany. A special shrine was constructed and this became the central feature of the new Cologne Cathedral, which was founded in 1248, nearly 50 years after the bones had reached the city.

In 1864 the shrine was opened and the bones of three men were found to be inside, together with a coin dating from the time of the shrine’s construction. Strange to tell, the ages of the bones showed that the men had died at different ages, one being quite young, one being middle-aged and the third being elderly. This would fit the legend that the wise men became Christians and were martyred, presumably at the same time.

However, the huge medieval appetite for relics and physical links to the Bible stories gives credence to the notion that somebody made a quick buck by persuading the Church that three particular sets of bones (possibly dug up from a graveyard) were those of the three wise men. It would not have been the first nor the last time that a conman made a fortune from the gullibility of simple-minded people.

The three wise men, who have been accorded the status of saints by the Roman Catholic Church, may therefore never have existed or, if they did, their personal details owe a lot more to fiction than to fact. But it’s a good story, and where would the traditional school nativity play be without its three kings?

© John Welford