Showing posts with label global warming. Show all posts
Showing posts with label global warming. Show all posts

Friday, 3 April 2020

Telling children the truth about climate change



It is the next generation, and the ones after that, that will have to live with the worst consequences of global warming, and it is therefore the duty of today’s adults to be completely straightforward and honest when it comes to telling today’s children about what they are likely to face.

There is a statistic that claims that one in seven British children hold their parents personally responsible – at least in part – for global warming. Perhaps the surprising thing is that the proportion is not even greater than that!

The important thing is for parents to have a good understanding themselves of all the issues, so that they can discuss them sensibly with their children and put everything they bring up into its proper context.

Perhaps the best thing a parent can encourage in their children is the need to examine not only the evidence but also the sources of that evidence.  There is an awful lot of misinformation about that is shoved out by people with personal agendas, or who are sponsored by organisations (such as fossil fuel companies) that have a vested interest in the world not taking climate change seriously.

It is no wonder that young people get confused. A parent can do a lot to dispel that confusion – just as long as they are not confused themselves!

© John Welford

Is the global warming pause over? Did it ever exist?




Global warming sceptics have long relied on the “pause” in rising world temperatures to bolster their claim that it is all a myth. However, recent evidence suggests that the pause may well be over, and that it may never even have existed in the first place.

The global warming hiatus

Measurements of average global temperatures, which have become increasingly sophisticated since the advent of satellite recording to add to land and sea observations, have shown an upward rise ever since the late 19th century.  These measurements have been incorporated in models of climate change that demonstrate worrying trends that could lead to very serious consequences for life on Earth in future generations.

However, despite the overall upward trend taken over the long term, there have been times when the steadiness of the rise has been called into question. In particular, the past 15 years appear to have demonstrated a pause or hiatus in the rise, with the overall global temperature rising very little, if at all.

Needless to say, this hiatus has provided welcome ammunition for the chorus of climate change deniers who would prefer to ignore the evidence gathered by the world’s huge army of climate scientists who are in almost universal agreement that global warming is real, is largely due to human activity, has potentially alarming consequences, and is something that the governments of the world should be taking urgent action to combat.

The deniers are concerned that action to slow down the rate of temperature rise will have severe consequences for the economies of the world’s wealthiest countries and lead to a decline in living standards. Their main weapon in furthering their claims is to try to refute the evidence produced by the climate scientists, and the “pause” is an important weapon which they have used to persuade others to their point of view.

But the pause may be over

The current evidence shows that global temperatures are once more moving upwards. Record highs have been recordeded in many parts of the world, including West Africa, South America and the Pacific Ocean. Antarctica had its warmest ever day in March 2015, with a temperature of 17.4⁰C (63.3⁰F) being recorded.

These 2015 record highs are on top of the previous records noted in 2014, thus showing that the upward spike was not a one-year blip. Ever cautious, climate scientists will not say that the evidence provides absolute certainty that the pause is over, but it very much looks as though this might be the case.

This is borne out by other evidence of continuing warming, such as there being less Arctic ice recorded than in any previous year and a rise in overall atmospheric carbon dioxide (a major driver of global warming) to more than 400 parts per million – the first time this has ever happened in human history.

Is El Nino to blame?

Climate science is extremely complex, with many factors being involved that can affect global temperatures one way or the other, and one of these is the phenomenon known as El Nino. This is a periodic warming of the waters of the Pacific Ocean that can have serious implications for weather patterns across the globe. However, the timing of the latest El Nino does not match the pattern of higher temperature recordings mentioned above. The world was already getting hotter before El Nino got going, and the expected rise due to El Nino will not be noticed until several months after it has peaked.

Is the pause a myth anyway?

However, some scientists are now claiming that there was never a global warming pause in the first place.

Scientists at the NOAA (US National Oceanic and Atmospheric Administration) have published a paper in “Science” that states that errors were made in the ocean temperature data collection methods used in past decades that led to a general underestimation of temperatures. Once these errors are accounted for, the upward trend is consistent with the earlier figures in showing a steady rise and no hiatus.

The differences come about from the change in data collection, from ships (measuring the temperature of water collected in buckets) to buoys, this change dating from the 1970s. The practice had always been to assume that the bucket-collection method produced higher temperatures, and these were accounted for in the figures used in climate models. However, these downward adjustments were still applied after buoys were used to record temperatures, despite their figures being more accurate. Once these adjustments are taken out of the reckoning, the hiatus is no longer to be seen.

In other words, the “pause” defence has ceased to be available to the climate change deniers. Whether one accepts the NOAA’s findings or not, the climate change pause is almost certainly a thing of the past.


© John Welford

For and against the "97% Consensus"




Climate sceptics are fond of challenging the oft-vaunted claim that 97% of climate scientists agree that current global warming is largely caused by mankind – the word commonly used is “anthropogenic”. So can that 97% figure be justified? Do the sceptics have a point?

Why 97%?  

This figure was arrived at in a study made in 2013 that examined the abstracts of nearly 12,000 papers on climate published between 1991 and 2011 in peer-reviewed journals. The criterion for including an abstract was a match with the terms “global climate change” or “global warming”.

Of these 12,000 abstracts, many (66.4%) did not offer an opinion on anthropogenic global warming (AGW), but of those that did (around 4,000 papers), 97.1% endorsed the consensus view that human activity is responsible for global warming.
The study (lead author John Cook of the Global Change Institute, Queensland, Australia) was published in the highly reputable Environmental Research Letters (Vol 8, No 2).

The overall conclusion of the study was: Our analysis indicates that the number of papers rejecting the consensus on AGW is a vanishingly small proportion of the published research.

This is not the only study that has produced a figure very close to 97%. For example, in 2009 Doran and Zimmermann concluded a 97% consensus, and in 2010 Anderegg et al reckoned that the actual figure was 97.5%. These researchers would have used different methods and criteria than those of Cook et al.

Cook et al also looked at the public’s perception of the consensus, and found a marked “consensus gap”. A representative sample of American people was asked the question: “How many scientists agree that humans are causing global warming?” The average response was around 50%, which therefore reveals a huge public misconception about what climate scientists believe is the cause of global warming.

The opposing view

This was expressed in the oft-quoted “Petition Project” that is widely touted as offering proof that the “97% consensus” figure is wildly optimistic.

The petition in question dates from 2007 and was issued by the “Oregon Institute of Science and Medicine”. By 2013 the petition organisers claimed that more than 32,000 American scientists had signed the petition, the main statement of which was:

“There is no convincing scientific evidence that human release of carbon dioxide, methane, or other greenhouse gases is causing or will, in the foreseeable future, cause catastrophic heating of the Earth's atmosphere and disruption of the Earth's climate.”

The fact that so many qualified people were prepared to put their names to this statement is taken as evidence that the 97% consensus must be false and that there is a considerable body of informed opinion that takes a very different point of view.

To be fair, it must be pointed out that the “Oregon Petition” is not the only attempt to come up with a similar conclusion. However, the attention directed towards the Petition, and the reliance placed on it by climate change deniers, make it a fair target for close examination.

A bogus petition

There are several circumstances surrounding the Petition that lead to the conclusion that it should not be taken seriously.

One of these is the status of the “Oregon Institute of Science and Medicine”. It sounds impressive, but in actual fact it is nothing of the sort. It sounds as though it ought to be research facility or a college, staffed by highly-qualified and well-respected personnel who undertake research at a high level and publish quality papers in the world’s leading scientific journals.

It turns out that the “Oregon Institute” is nothing more than a cover name for a small group of climate change deniers led by Dr Arthur B Robinson, whose doctorate is in chemistry. He has done no research in climate science and his motivation for entering the field appears to be entirely political (he has stood for the US Congress as a Republican).

As for the Petition itself, it claimed to be based on a rigorous selection procedure that ensured that it was only signed by suitably qualified people. In reality, anyone with a Bachelor’s degree in a scientific discipline was entitled to sign it, and very few checks were carried out with a view to weeding out signatories who were doing so from a purely political motive.

The reality is that the criteria for signing were so weak that more than 10 million people were qualified to sign, and 32,000 therefore represents a tiny minority of potential signatories.

The Petition was accompanied by an initially impressive document that appeared to be a reprint from a peer-reviewed journal and to be endorsed by the National Academy of Science.  This paper included graphs and other “evidence” that poured scorn on the consensus view of global warming. However, it was riddled with errors and misleading statements – so much so that the National Academy felt constrained to issue a rejoinder that dissociated itself from the Petition and declared that it was “a deliberate attempt to mislead scientists”.

Who do you trust?

So the question boils down to – Who do you trust to be more reliable when it comes to speaking the truth about the consensus on global warming?

On the one hand you have rigorous studies, conducted by people with pristine credentials, that make use of sound research published in peer-reviewed journals. On the other hand you have politically-motivated “cod science” in the form of a petition organised by highly dubious individuals and conducted in a manner that was far from scientific and nowhere close to being statistically sound.

And yet, for reasons best known to themselves, the climate change deniers tell us that we should be paying more attention to the latter than the former!

© John Welford

Four questions for global warming deniers




I can see nothing in what we are told by the world’s climate scientists to make me doubt that the world is warming, that human activity has a great deal to do with it, that this is a highly dangerous trend, and that it is high time that we all agreed on getting on and doing something about it.

However, there is a tiny but highly vocal minority of people (mostly but not exclusively Americans) who seem to have a problem in understanding this. When I have tried to argue the case with these people they tend to get very “waffly” and usually fail to make any statements that reveal what they truly believe is happening to the world’s climate.

So here are four questions that I would like any global warming sceptic who reads this to answer:

1. Does the atmosphere contain carbon dioxide?
2. Does atmospheric carbon dioxide raise the average global temperature?
3. Will this influence be enhanced by the addition of more carbon dioxide?
4.  Have human activities led to a net emission of carbon dioxide?

If you answer No to any of these questions, I would like you to justify your answer, because it will fly in the face of all the evidence that has been collected by thousands of people over a long period of time. Why is your No more reliable than their Yes?

© John Welford

Why we need to fly a lot less




It is well known that transport is a major contributor to greenhouse gas emissions, mainly due to the fact that most forms of transport are powered by fossil fuels, the burning of which leads to the release of carbon dioxide and other waste products, some of which are also greenhouse gases. In the UK, for example, 22% of greenhouse gases come from road vehicles.

However, the increased popularity of flying is a fast-growing problem. If an express coach takes 50 people from London to Edinburgh, the total emission of carbon dioxide will be around 460 kilograms. If those 50 people fly, the journey will be a lot faster, but they will be responsible for depositing no less than 4820 kilograms of CO₂ into the atmosphere – more than ten times as much.

If they let the train take the strain the emissions would come to 595 kilograms – more than by coach but far less than by air. Given the fact that trains run from city centre to city centre and therefore save a huge amount of time that has to be used in getting to and from airports, checking in and collecting baggage, it may indeed turn out that the train is the quicker option.

The annual figure recorded by the Department for Transport for emissions by aircraft is 2.5 million tonnes. However, this is just for domestic flights; if the UK’s share of international aviation is included (i.e. half of all flights taking off or landing in the UK) then the figure is more than ten times higher.

Another factor to bear in mind is that aircraft create pollution high in the atmosphere and not just at or near ground level. How much difference this makes is uncertain, but conservative estimates put aviation as being responsible for 13% of the UK’s total impact on climate change.

What can be done to cut these figures?

Clearly there needs to be a lot less flying done, both within the UK and internationally. This applies to business and leisure flying and also air freight.

A major change in recent years has been the growth of “no frills” cut-price aviation companies that have encouraged more people to take flights and on more occasions. People now think nothing of hopping on a plane to take a weekend break as well as several week-long holidays in places such as Majorca, the Greek islands and Turkey. Many people look even further afield and regularly cross the Atlantic for a holiday. Even if they only took one foreign holiday break a year, and stuck to the UK for other breaks – not involving flights – they would make a huge difference to carbon emissions.

The Government could certainly encourage such a trend by making flights more expensive through increased taxation, as well as abandoning any proposal to build new airport capacity in the London area.

Given the increasing use of the Internet for doing business, such as international video-conferencing, is it really necessary for so many business flights to take place? Surely there is room for huge savings in carbon emissions from the business community alone, simply by executives asking themselves the question: “Is your flight really necessary?” and answering No more often than Yes.

The ordinary food consumer could also make a huge contribution by ceasing to demand items that are out of season in the UK but can be imported from overseas relatively cheaply via air freight.

Granted, some crops cannot be grown locally, but, for those that can be, there is no excuse for demanding access to them throughout the year. We need to go back to the days when dietary habits varied according to season and imported food came via ship rather than aircraft.

We also need to cut out practices such as that of flying shellfish from the UK to Southeast Asia so that it can be packed by cheap labour before being flown back for sale in supermarkets only a few miles from where it started!

It is high time that common sense prevailed over raw economics. The climate is far more important than filling the pockets of wealthy businessmen, which seems to be the only criterion that some people are taking seriously.

© John Welford

Thursday, 2 April 2020

Meat eating and climate change




The desire of human beings to eat meat is having a devastating impact on the planet we live on. This is not only because of the destructive pattern of land use that results but also because of the behaviour of the vast numbers of animals that are reared for food.

Grassland depletion

An amazing statistic is that 26% of all the world’s farmland is used for grazing livestock and another 33% is used for growing food to be fed to livestock. Some of this land has been created by destroying ecosystems such as natural woodland, and some of it was originally grassland used by native species that are no longer welcome.

The effects of man’s hunger for meat are seen in places like Brazil, where half of the natural grassland, interspersed with wooded areas, has either been turned into land that is suitable for cattle raising (i.e. minus the woods and forests) or ploughed up for the growing of soybeans for animal feed.

Much of the heartland of the United States was once prairie grassland that extended over vast areas and supported millions of bison, which were in turn hunted in a sustainable way by Native Americans. However, farming and the raising of cattle has reduced the original prairie to less than 5% of its original extent.

Farmed and natural animals compete with each other in a number of ways, with the latter always losing out.  One particular constraint on natural species is the interruption to their migration routes caused by large-scale animal husbandry.

Livestock and climate change

Livestock, especially when raised in large numbers, have a direct impact on the process of climate change. This is especially true of cattle which, due to their digestive system, emit large of amounts of methane – mainly in the form of burps rather than from the rear end.

An average cow releases between 70 and 120 kg of methane per year. Like carbon dioxide, methane is a greenhouse gas, but it is much more harmful. Every 100 kg of methane released into the atmosphere has the equivalent effect of 2,300 kg of carbon dioxide. This is in turn the equivalent of what would be produced by burning 1000 litres of petrol. To put it another way, a cow grazing in a field for a year does as much damage to the atmosphere as a car being driven for 7,800 miles.

Given that there are 1.5 billion cows and bulls in the world that are raised for beef and dairy produce, the equivalent of two billion metric tons of carbon dioxide are contributing to global warming every year, on top of which must be added 2.8 billion metric tons that result from the clearing of natural forests and woodland to create more grazing land.

Agriculture is responsible for 18% of all greenhouse gas emissions, which is more than is produced by all modes of transport worldwide. Although other farmed animals produce carbon dioxide and methane, cattle are by far the worst culprits.

What can be done about it?

At the heart of this crisis is the growing appetite of humans for beef and dairy products. The demand for beef has grown enormously thanks to companies such as MacDonalds that have been particularly successful in marketing a product cheaply and in bulk. They have created worldwide demand and persuaded many millions of people to change their eating habits to include much more meat in their diet.

The net result has been disastrous both for the environment and for human health, with many more cases of cancer and heart disease resulting from the consumption of excess animal protein.

Government action is therefore needed to rein in the beef industry (by making their products more expensive and cutting all subsidies) and encourage farmers to switch from raising cattle to growing plant-based food for direct human consumption.

However, because demand drives supply, it is essential that we all reduce our demand for products that are doing Planet Earth far more harm than most people realise.

© John Welford

Man-made climate change began earlier than we once thought




Most people, when asked about the impact of mankind on climate change, would assume that this is a relatively recent phenomenon caused by the steady increase in recent decades of carbon dioxide emissions due to such things as air travel and motor vehicles, as well as heavy industry.

However, the evidence suggests that human-induced climate change began as long ago as the early decades of the 19th century, not long after the Industrial Revolution led to fossil fuels (notably coal) being burned in large quantities.

Ocean evidence

The evidence comes from data gathered by examining ocean corals and other marine organisms. This source of data is vital because the oceans have absorbed more than 90% of the warming caused by climate change, and corals can provide temperature data going back at least 500 years.

Effect of volcanoes

Evidence of global warming would have difficult to spot in earlier decades if only land-based measurements were relied upon. This is in part because the early 19th century experienced several massive volcanic eruptions, most notably that of Mount Tambora in 1815, that had an overall cooling effect on global temperatures and masked any rises due to other causes. Any mid-century rise would be seen as a natural recovery from the earlier cooling as the atmospheric dust clouds dispersed.
However, computer simulations that remove the effect of volcanic eruptions from the data show very clearly that there was a notable rise in temperatures from the 1830s that can only have industrial emissions as the cause.

Steady rise

These models are in line with the evidence from ocean corals and show very clearly that climate change from human causes dates from the mid-19th century and has been increasing ever since.

© John Welford

Believing what you want to on climate change





We only seem to believe what we want to believe

It seems to be a natural human trait to believe what is most comfortable to believe, whether or not that belief accords with the available evidence. This is very evident in matters of religion and politics, which are both areas in which it is notoriously difficult to persuade someone to change their beliefs or to convince them that they are being irrational by believing what they do.

This phenomenon seems to be prevalent in the debate over climate change, and particularly on the question of whether the current wave of global warming is the result of human activity.

The evidence is mounting on the side of “yes it is”. The Intergovernmental Panel on Climate Change issues regular reports on the issue, and it is noticeable that the percentage of likelihood that man-made emissions are the cause has risen steadily as each report has been issued over the years. In their second report, in 1995, the figure was 50 per cent – now it is 95 per cent. The number of scientists contributing to this view is enormous, with more than 600 contributing to the report and more than 30,000 offering comments. This is just about as close to consensus as you could ever hope to get.

And yet, with the wealth of evidence growing, the number of climate change deniers is also on the increase! The proportion of people who take this line has quadrupled since 2005, and support for alternative energy schemes has fallen. Why?

My view is that, as stated above, people have a tendency to believe what they want to believe is true, even when it is not. If human beings are causing global warming , then those same human beings are going to have to take drastic action to slow it down and avoid the catastrophe that could face our planet if we do nothing.  This is not something that anyone can accept with any degree of pleasure, so it is a lot easier to stick one’s head in the sand and pretend that the problem does not exist.

What is likely to happen?

A generally accepted prediction is that the average temperature of the planet could rise by four degrees Celsius by the year 2100, and that would mean that it could support a human population of no more than one billion as opposed to the seven billion that exist today.

That is a horrifying prospect for our descendants, as it implies mass starvation for vast areas of the planet, preceded by conflicts over resources of unimaginable proportions.

And how are we reacting today?  Largely by ignoring the issue altogether and not allowing ourselves to believe what we are being told! All this talk is very uncomfortable and we would much prefer to bother ourselves with other matters.
Just as some people like to believe that there are fairies at the bottom of the garden, because that is nice and comfortable, so they like to imagine, in some quarters, that the whole “climate change thing” is a massive scam to make us pay higher taxes!

It’s time to get real, folks, and start believing what the vast majority of climate scientists are telling us – it is our doing, and we’d better start mending our ways if we want our children’s children to have a future.

© John Welford

Simple ways to be greener




Like Kermit the Frog, you could sit back and say that “it’s not easy being green” and just do nothing about it. After all, you might say, what difference can I make by myself? If nobody else bothers, why should I?

But the fact is that millions of people ARE bothering, and if more people did so, then a real difference would be made. And all the small things you can do will produce a huge cumulative effect, as well as saving you money along the way.

For a start, you could have a good look around you and examine absolutely everything that consumes energy or resources. Start with your house or apartment; start right now with the room you are sitting in as you read this.  How many lights are you burning? How many do you need? What kind of bulb is in the light you are using now?  If it is not a low-energy bulb, why on earth not?

When you last watched TV, did you leave it on standby or turn it off at the mains?  When you last boiled the kettle for a cup of coffee, did you boil the whole kettle just for one cup? I take it you got the milk out of the refrigerator, but what setting is it on?  Do you really need it that high? And how full is it?  It’s wasteful to cool just air if you don’t store a lot of food.  Maybe a smaller fridge would suit you better.

What about your hot water supply? Are you using the most economical settings or are you heating water that you don’t need and will only cool down again?  Did you shower or have a bath today?  Would it make a heap of difference if you didn’t shower every morning?  By the way, a power shower is hugely wasteful of both water and energy; what’s wrong with a normal shower unit?

What about your toilet cistern?  You could save water by placing a house brick in it so that it takes less water to fill it.  Remember not to leave taps running when cleaning your teeth.

To make your central heating more efficient, make sure that the heat doesn’t escape through open doors and windows.  If you have an open fireplace that you are not using, insert a chimney balloon; this is a simple device that you shove up the chimney and inflate so that you heat your room and not the air above your house.

And, of course, recycle everything you possibly can. You can compost even small amounts of waste food in an enclosed digester “powered” by worms.  This will produce not only excellent compost for your garden but liquid feed for your house plants. There is no reason why glass, metal, plastic or card should go to incinerators or landfill; it can all be recycled.

Other resolutions can include the purchases you make. With motor fuel increasing in price, the incentive is there to avoid buying a gas guzzler and instead go for something that consumes less fuel and thus pumps fewer pollutants into the atmosphere. And when you have the car, why not resolve to use it less? Do you really need to take all those short journeys by car? Why not walk or cycle instead, or use public transport? Also, did you know that the way you drive your car can make a huge difference to your fuel consumption? Exceeding the speed limits is not illegal but expensive.

When shopping for food, don’t buy more food than you are actually going to consume. A huge amount of the food we buy, often as a result of taking up special offers, goes to waste. Also, avoid buying food that is out of season; it has either been grown under artificial conditions that consume energy unnecessarily or it has been transported across the world, causing greenhouse gases to be released in the process.

And don’t expect the foodstore to provide the bags in which you will take it all home. Many stores now offer a “bag for life”, for example; buy the bags you need and use them time after time. Better still, order your groceries from home and get the store to deliver them. The road miles covered by their delivery van will be far fewer than would have been travelled by all the people whose food is being delivered at the same time.

When it comes to making vacation plans, think very hard about the environmental consequences of jetting off to the sun. Atmospheric pollution, leading to global warming, is far worse when delivered high in the atmosphere than at ground level, and therefore the fewer flights we take, the better. You can have an enjoyable and relaxing break much closer to home than you might imagine.

Going completely green is not always easy, but it is amazing what you can do on a small scale that will save you money and make a real difference to saving the planet as well.

© John Welford

Sea level rises that could result from global warming





Climate change could lead to sea levels rising to a point where low-lying parts of the world would be devastated. Indeed, this is widely regarded as inevitable. But just how high are sea levels likely to reach – and when will this happen?

Global temperatures rising by two degrees Celsius

This measure of two degrees relates to the difference between average global temperatures now and what they were before the Industrial Revolution that began in Western Europe in the late 18th century. It is thought that restricting the rise to two degrees offers the best hope of preventing the disastrous consequences that many climate scientists predict. However, this will not be easy if action is not taken now to restrict the burning of fossil fuels.

The 2-degree temperature rise will in any case lead to a general sea level rise of 0.8 metres, simply from the effect of water expanding as it gets warmer. This effect is already taking place, the effects being noticed particularly in low-lying island nations.

Antarctic ice shelves are set to collapse

The polar ice caps are repositories of vast quantities of frozen water. One of the chief dangers of global warming is that enough of this ice will melt to cause significant sea-level rises.

Scientists at the University of Washington in Seattle have concluded that at least one vast ice shelf in Antarctica is bound to collapse, whatever steps are taken to limit global warming. This is because the processes leading to collapse are irreversible.

An ice shelf is a tongue of ice that is fed by glaciers and projects beyond the continent into the surrounding sea. The shelf that is causing concern is about two kilometres thick, but its base can be reached by relatively warm oceanic water that causes melting. There would be no problem if the rate of melting was matched by the supply of extra ice from above in the form of glaciers from off the land, but this is no longer the case because the glaciers are in retreat. As sea ice melts, more water will be able to reach the base of the shelf and cause further melting.

When the ice shelf collapses and all its ice turns to liquid water, the eventual result will be a global sea level rise of 3.3 metres. If other glacial melting is taken into account, as well as the 0.8 metres rise mentioned above, the total expected rise will be 4.5 metres.

Is that all?

Not necessarily! The hope that the global temperature rise will plateau at +2 degrees is just that – a hope. What would be the likely scenario if the rise was, say, 4 degrees?

The answer is – a great deal worse. For one thing, there are other ice shelves in Antarctica that would be vulnerable to collapse. For another, the Greenland ice cap is at risk and its point of no return could be reached within the next 50 years.

If all this happened, and all the at-risk ice melted, a 4.5 metre rise in global sea levels would be just the start. The overall rise could be as high as 19 metres! The lower figure would be enough to inundate places such as the Netherlands and Florida, but a rise four times as great would have consequences that are hard to imagine.

But when?

It could take one or two centuries for the +4.5 metre level to be reached, but it certainly will be reached at some future point because the processes currently in motion are irreversible.

The worst scenario – a 19 metre rise – could be thousands of years down the road.

However, a one metre rise – which would have very serious consequences for low-lying nations – could easily be something that many people alive today will see and have to contend with.

Can it be stopped?

That depends on what is meant by “it”. As mentioned above, some degree of sea level rise is inevitable, and even the predicted 4.5 metre rise will have severe repercussions for future generations. Plans for future human settlement need to bear this in mind, because there are many places in the world where this will  simply be impossible and there is absolutely nothing that can be done to rectify the situation.

However, it is still within the realm of human ingenuity to prevent the worst scenario – a 19 metre rise – from occurring a lot further down the line. Global warming can be slowed to a manageable level if humanity is sensible in the way it uses energy in the future – primarily by keeping fossil fuels in the ground and using every opportunity to exploit renewable energy sources.

There are plenty of examples already evident of how this can be done – in the UK there have been several days in recent months on which more electricity has been generated from renewables than from oil and coal. Developments in battery design are proceeding apace, which gives cause for hope that more energy produced by, for example, solar and wind can be stored and released when needed.

What is needed most is a universal belief that the problems can be solved and refusal by governments across the world to listen to the blandishments of fossil fuel producers whose only concern is immediate profit.

The relatively short-term prospect is not good for preventing major sea level rises. However, the longer-term prospects are much more hopeful, as long we take seriously our responsibility for future generations.

© John Welford